What is in question: Jeremiah calls Jeconiah childless, yet other biblical lists continue his family line, so the issue is whether the word means no children at all or no successful royal heir.

One reading

Childless means no throne successor

majoritygraph path

Claim: Jeremiah's judgment means no descendant of Jeconiah will prosper on David's throne, not that Jeconiah has no descendants.

Basis: Jeremiah 22:30 explains the judgment in throne language, while 1 Chronicles 3:17 and Matthew 1:12 continue the line after Jeconiah.

Who holds it: not attributed to a named source in this dataset

Verses:

Another reading

The wording still creates a tension

minority

Claim: The word "childless" can sound absolute, so readers still have to notice the tension when a genealogy lists descendants after Jeconiah.

Basis: Jeremiah 22:30 says to write Jeconiah childless; 1 Chronicles 3:17 and Matthew 1:12 place Shealtiel after Jeconiah.

Who holds it: not attributed to a named source in this dataset

Verses:

Scholarly weight: The no-throne-successor reading is the wider and stronger reading because Jeremiah 22:30 itself defines the judgment in royal-throne terms. The second reading is a caution about wording, not an equal scholarly alternative.

Graph note: The graph keeps the Jeconiah to Shealtiel link because the genealogical texts name it; the note flags the wording of Jeremiah rather than treating it as an equal unresolved scholarly split.

Where scholars differ

Which father names should be followed for Shealtiel and Zerubbabel?

What is in question: Different biblical lists attach Shealtiel and Zerubbabel to different fathers, so the issue is which textual witness is being followed at each link.

One reading

Zerubbabel is son of Shealtiel

majority

Claim: Several texts call Zerubbabel the son of Shealtiel, so this is the most repeated biblical wording for Zerubbabel's father.

Basis: Matthew 1:12 and Luke 3:27 put Zerubbabel after Shealtiel; Ezra 3:2 and Haggai 1:1 call Zerubbabel son of Shealtiel.

Who holds it: not attributed to a named source in this dataset

Verses:

Another reading

Zerubbabel is son of Pedaiah

contested

Claim: 1 Chronicles names Pedaiah as Zerubbabel's father, so that link cannot be erased when comparing the lists.

Basis: 1 Chronicles 3:19 says the sons of Pedaiah were Zerubbabel and Shimei.

Who holds it: not attributed to a named source in this dataset

Verses:

A third reading

Shealtiel is linked to Jeconiah or Neri

contested

Claim: Matthew and 1 Chronicles associate Shealtiel with Jeconiah, while Luke places Neri before Shealtiel.

Basis: 1 Chronicles 3:17 and Matthew 1:12 connect Shealtiel with Jeconiah; Luke 3:27 calls Shealtiel son of Neri.

Who holds it: not attributed to a named source in this dataset

Verses:

Scholarly weight: For Zerubbabel, Shealtiel is the more widely repeated biblical father-name, but Pedaiah remains a real Chronicles counter-witness. For Shealtiel's own father, Matthew/Chronicles and Luke preserve different lines, and this apparatus does not choose a harmonization.

Graph note: The graph retains all cited edges as textual witnesses rather than collapsing them into one harmonized family tree.

1 Chronicles 3:17 names Shealtiel as son of Jeconiah. Matthew 1:12 also names Shealtiel after Jeconiah; the broader Jeconiah childlessness crux is flagged when Matthew is processed. Matthew 1:12 and 1 Chronicles 3:17 name Shealtiel in the Jeconiah line; flagged for review with the Jeconiah crux.

This person is flagged in the data for textual or identification review.

Jeconiah -> Shealtiel Flagged for review. Jeconiah to Shealtiel is a known review point because Matthew 1:12 and 1 Chronicles 3:17 name Shealtiel after Jeconiah while Jeremiah 22:30 is relevant to interpretation; no harmonization is shown here.

Neri -> Shealtiel Flagged for review. Luke 3:27 names Shealtiel as son of Neri; Matthew 1:12 and 1 Chronicles 3:17 place Shealtiel after Jeconiah. Both are retained and flagged for review.

Shealtiel -> Zerubbabel Flagged for review. Matthew 1:12 names Shealtiel as father of Zerubbabel; 1 Chronicles 3:19 names Pedaiah as father of Zerubbabel. Both cited edges are retained and flagged for review.